REVIEWS
Workbook on the Two Over One
System by Mike Lawrence
Reviewed By Alan Shook
In this book, Mike Lawrence has written not a 2/1
system reference but rather, as the title implies, a guide to help the reader
sort through the pertinent issues and craft a playable 2/1 dialect reflecting
his own preferences.
This book is best read with a favorite partner.
The partnership will need experience playing a 5 card major system such as SAYC
or other Standard American dialects and be looking to refine their agreements
into a playable 2/1 system. A set of system notes, perhaps as simple as an ACBL
convention card, is a useful complementary document to guide a discussion of
the points Lawrence makes.
The second chapter contains a list of the
"must" questions to be answered, reflecting the various 2/1 dialects. In this
chapter, Lawrence poses the questions, offers the possible answers, explains
the extended implications and the advantages and disadvantages of each. For
example, he addresses the question of "is a two-over-always game forcing or are
there possible exceptions?" by presenting these examples:
| |
West |
East |
| ª |
AKJ87 |
5 |
| © |
A862 |
K53 |
| ¨ |
75 |
A8 |
| § |
Q2 |
AKJT875 |
| |
|
|
| |
West |
East |
| |
1ª |
2§ |
| |
2© |
3§ |
| |
4§ |
4¨ |
| |
4© |
5© |
| |
5NT |
7§ |
Here he says, by making 3§ forcing, the partnership can conduct a delicate cue
bidding auction ending in the very good Grand Slam. If 3§ is not forcing East could not bid 3§, resulting in wasted space or distorted shape.
He goes on to show the downside to the 100% game forcing agreement.
Lawrence's position is that if 2§ is
game forcing, then 3§ must be weak and
preemptive and 1NT (forcing) followed by 3§ must be used to show an invitational hand. He makes a
set of recommendations but his reasoning and the explanation of the
interrelationships between the answers exemplifies his approach throughout the
workbook. In the end, a partnership can use this book to work out a set of
agreements confident that the crafted agreements are consistent and complete.
This work is typical of Mike Lawrence's writings. It is not meant for
a casual read. It will require an active participation of (preferably) a
partnership, but a reward the readers will have a foundation for building a
bidding system that is playable and sound. |